Mar 30 2010
Assignment #9 – E is for Evaluate
Flat Stanley Blog
How will you know if this site is helping your users reach the objectives you’ve defined for them?
To reprise the objectives stated in the A is for Analyze post, this is what I want users to be able to do as a result of participating in this project – so when I see the following, I will know that the site, Manner’s Miners, is a success:
- The teacher builds and maintains a Weebly website.
- The teacher manages a Weebly blog by: posting prompts, reviewing student posts, approving or deleting student posts.
- Students build and maintain a Weebly website.
- Students add features and content to their website in response to teacher’s prompts.
- Students compose paragraphs in response to their teacher’s prompts, in compliance with California writing standards for fourth grade.
- Students post their paragraphs on the teacher’s class blog.
- Students post meaningful comments in response to their classmates’ blog posts.
To more descriptively say what I’m looking for:
- I will know that the site is effective when I see posts from the partner school in Scotland and when I see the site grow and change as the teachers and students become more comfortable with the Weebly platform.
- A successful learning site will also show evidence of user growth as posts improve technically and in content quality. I will be looking for evidence that students in Scotland and Students in Rocklin have learned something from each other that they would not have learned without this collaborative project. I know that the students are engaged and having fun because I have observed them, and I know what fun looks like. I am looking for evidence that what they are doing is meaningful.
- We prepared for the telecollaboration by practicing with faculty and staff, and a partner class at our own school. The results to date are encouraging. All of Ms. Manner’s students responded to her first prompt, as did most of the students in our partner fourth grade class. Ms. Manner’s students then posted comments in response to those responses, so we are confident that students are “getting” the cycle of comment and response.
- We are also encouraged by the good internet behavior students have demonstrated in the tone of their work. We have been pretty lax regarding writing style in order to get the words flowing. We do plan to gradually ramp up the rigor of the writing standard. Ms. Manner will design the rubric and introduce it to the students. I have suggested that she use RubiStar.
- Ultimately, I will know that this project is successful if other teachers want to give it a try. Teachers believe other teachers. If Ms. Manner is successful with her site and blog, she will share that success with her peers. I can’t think of a more powerful advocate than a satisfied customer; likewise, if the project does not go well the tom-tom’s will be beating out that message! Ms. Manner’s students’ success is her success, and mine!

